Jump to content
Post-Update: Forum Issues Read more... ×
BPAL Madness!
  • entries
    69
  • comments
    165
  • views
    5,213

University-related question.

Sign in to follow this  
filigree_shadow

402 views

Here's a strange question for you. What do you do when you realize that your professor is giving wrong answers in class?

 

Last quarter I had a 300-level anatomy class. This quarter I have a 100-level physiology class. This is the first time this professor has taught at Northwestern -- usually she teaches at a community college.

 

Last week she mis-identified a bone on her own lecture slide as a humerus when it was very clearly a femur. She sort of hemmed and hawed over it for a couple of seconds and then said humerus. So it wasn't just an oral typo.

 

Last night she spelled the muscle sternocleidomastoid wrong on her lecture slide, and then she mispronounced it as well. But the real kicker was that she had it up there as an example of how muscles are sometimes named based on their points of insertion. She said this muscle is named for its three insertion points: the sternum, the clavicle [both true] and... "mastication, which is chewing, which means it goes into your neck." Ummm... no. It's attached to the mastoid process, which is a piece of the temporal bone of the skull that sticks down behind your ear.

 

I realize she may need to simplify some explanations because it's a 100-level class, but simplify does not mean the same thing as "tell students the wrong answer." When a student asked her what the difference was between "extends the thigh" and "extends the leg" when we were talking about different muscle functions, she didn't know the answer. Our anatomy professor beat us over the head with learning to call the upper part of the lower limb the "thigh" and the lower part of the lower limb the "leg." She told us specifically not to call the whole lower limb the "leg" because that was anatomically incorrect. So why did my physiology professor not know that?

 

I don't know what to do here. I paid full Northwestern tuition for this class, and this is the first time at Northwestern that I felt like I was getting a crappy education for my money. All my other Northwestern professors have been stellar.

 

Should I go to the dean? Should I ask my advisor what I should do? I've never been in this situation before and I don't know how to approach this.

Sign in to follow this  


2 Comments


Recommended Comments

You're paying serious money for that class, I am sure, and at the very least you should bring up your concerns to your advisor, or to the dean.

Share this comment


Link to comment

You're paying serious money for that class, I am sure, and at the very least you should bring up your concerns to your advisor, or to the dean.

 

Thanks! I sent an email to my advisor, and she was very concerned (as she should be, I think). She told me that for new professors, the students fill out a mid-term evaluation halfway through the quarter in order to give the professor a chance to fix mistakes rather than waiting until the class evaluation at the end of the quarter to get feedback. She also gave me a phone number for the dean -- she told me that I can call and be anonymous.

 

Not too anonymous, however... there are only 3 or 4 students in the whole class (of about 35) that had anatomy before taking this class, so if an anonymous student says her anatomical descriptions in class are wrong, I bet she'll be able to figure out who it is. Especially since I had to tell her on the quiz last week that she had left one of the answers out of the "word bank" for our multiple choice questions and she had to announce two new words to add in the middle of the quiz. :hugs: I never think students should correct teachers in class, but come on. That was pretty bad.

Share this comment


Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×