I didn't do this for other etailers, so I will make it easy on you, Witchy of mine.

BPAL/BPTP: (Huge list... lots of options, but none expected)

Halloween in the Miskatonic University Library, Wolf Spider, Pumpkin III, Pumpkin V, Satan Talks to Sin and Death, Die Sunde, Vom Tod Verfolgt, Undine Comes Into The House of the Fishermen, Buen Viaje, Nadie Se Conocem Monastery in the Mountains, The Tomb of Zai

C8H10N4O2 soap, Pumpkin Tart soap, Pumpkin Pie bath oil, Red Velvet Truffle bath oil, Spider Silk bath oil, Red Pumpkin Floss perfume oil, All Souls candle, Pumpkin Tart candle, The nommy candy

The Atrocious Attic, The Lurid Library, The Perilous Parlour, The Wretched Rose Window, Boo, Dia De Los Muertos, Fizzy Jack O'Lantern, Ghost House, Mango Infused Pumpkin Chai Latte, Pomona, Punkie Night, and Sugar Skull

From the Arcana LEs, I would like to try:

Poison Candy

Spirit & Shadow Perfume

Claws & Teeth Perfume

Goat God Soap

All Souls Island Soap

Reign in Hell Perfume

Darkling Perfume

Song of Songs: Honey and Milk

Skeleton Key Soap (If this comes in perfume DO WANT)

Haint Soap

Dia de los Muertos Soap

Also, while looking on The Soap Box Company, I found Masala Chai Lip Balm by Naiad. THIS IS A THING?! Has anyone used Naiad before?

From Villainess: (Not picky on the actual product, be it soap, whipped, smooch, etc. So I am just listing scents that look yummers)

Candy Floss Cupcake

Cocoa Berry Cream Cheese

Mango Spicecake

Moral Decay

Mudslide (Vetiver can be iffy, but it seems interesting)

Three Cakes

From Nocturne Alchemy: (I have Hathor and LOVELOVELOVE)

Dragon Vanille

Nilla Cocoa Bats

Sarcophagus

Jack Spice: Haunted Vanilla

Golden Butterscotch Marshmallow Ghost Tree

Hallow Girl

Miss Witch

Scary Cat

From Haunt:

Witch-Wife perfume oil

Pomona perfume oil

Gloaming perfume oil

Cinnamon Girl perfume oil

Sweet Cream lust

Honey lust

Bettie lust

Violet lust

Halloween:

Lavender Spiced Tea lust (OMNOMNOM)

Candy Corn lust

Caramel Apple lust

Pumpkin Cake lust

Claw and Cobblestones (Could be good, could be bad... patchouli and gingersnaps are a little iffy for me, but the rest sounds DIVINE!)

Burying Tree

Coffee Fiend

ANY of her handmade soaps.

Will update with more soon.

See my Notes of Win/Notes of Fail list. I am always willing to try new things!!! Notes are a good guideline for soap, but not the be all and end all. Soaps are more flexible since they aren't a constantly-used thing.