galahad

Kumari Kandam might fit the bill as well It definitely has a chill and the florals are soft and have a Pacific vibe for me

In The Bottle Dragon's blood and wine On Application The rose emerges softly through the dragons blood. Quite nice Dry Down The rose becomes a little strong for me but it is quite pretty overall Rating (0-5) 2.5

In The Bottle Mainly soft pine - fir perhaps? On Application Eucalyptus and fir Dry Down I don't really get any berry. Not for me. Rating (0-5) 1

In The Bottle Jamine and spice On Application Strong jasmine and lemon. The lemon tames the jasmine somewhat Dry Down Not bad but I am not a jasmine fan Rating (0-5) 1.5

In The Bottle The jasmine scares me but surprisingly I can smell daffodil On Application Surprisingly plummy with a floral backing. The jasmine and orchid seem to be behaving Dry Down The combination of plum, florals and musk give this a surprising tea-like scent. I like it but don't love it Rating (0-5) 2.5

In The Bottle Veeery woody and spicy. Definitely clove and pepper. Love! On Application Wow this is powerful. Very, very dry and spicy. Dry Down There is almost a soft vanillary note in this which I think might be the skin musk which pulls the shapr spices back a bit. Overall this smells like an old wooden spice chest which has been well used. A definite bottle of this in my future. Rating (0-5) 5

In The Bottle Fruity and buttery brandy. I'm scared as butter doesn't work on me! On Application The butter note immediately dissipates on the skin leaving an incredibly rich brandy/pastry/fruit scent. Dry Down This really doesn't morph from the above. It stays rich, boozey and kind of foody. I like it but not a bottle purchase for me, I think Rating (0-5) 3.5

In The Bottle I get bay, bourbon vanilla and patchoulil with a touch of clove and a general greenness. Smells amazing in the bottle On Application As amazing as this was in the bottle multiply that by 100 once it touches skin. The sandalwood is definitely toasted! Dry, woody and slightly spicy Dry Down Damn! I wish I had ordered 10 bottles of this before it disappeared. As most of the other reviewers have pointed out this has the lovely soft and smooth clove that Beth uses. It is golden and glowing. Just stunning. I know Beth does amazing ice/snow and dirt based scents but it always amazes me how she can get the feeling of fur/feathers in a scent. Mole was a classic example and this is another. While this does go through an unsettling celery stage as it dries down I am sure that will disappear as the bottle ages. Rating (0-5) 5

In The Bottle Bay rum and OMG leather in the bottle On Application Quite cool and dank on the skin. Definitely leather and bay rum with a woody resin which i assume is the massoia bark. Dry Down This ranks up there with my favourite leather scents (Brom Bones, Western Diamondback, The Black Rider) yet is very different for any of those primarily due to the bay rum and opium residue. The wool note that I love from BPAL comes out quite quickly. This is the only scent from the Neverwhere range that I absolutely had to try and I am gald I did. I love it. The end result is kind of green herbal, leather and incense. Rating (0-5) 4.5

In The Bottle Tobacco and smoke with just a faint trace of leather On Application Seems to have a good dose of vetiver in this. Very smoky and that is all I smell at this stage Dry Down Surprisingly this softens quite quickly with the smoke/vetiver backing away to let through the glorious tobacco and something that smells suspiciously like a man's cologne. And then it becomes soft, papery and dusty with a whiff of incense. The leather backs everything up but is not really apparent. Gorgeous Rating (0-5) 4.5

In The Bottle Sweet and sharp. I get a strong liquorice/anise vibe On Application The mildew note is prominent and kind of funky and then the tea quickly comes through strongly with a touch of vanilla smoothness. It still has an anise quality to it. Dry Down I was really looking forward to the mildewed raincoat note as this is a really comforting memory scent for me and I am not disappointed as this dries down. This is a new love for me. It is strangely soft and very definitely masculine for me ( I rarely put masculine and femine attributes to BPAL scents). Lovely and I suspect will age superbly. Rating (0-5) 4.5

In The Bottle Boozy, boozy rum and lime On Application Definitely fruity with the rum. The lime keeps it from becoming super syrupy Dry Down This is an amazing morpher on me. From the initial burts of rum and fruit it changes to strong ginger and then if goes kind of perfumey floral before the ginger comes back. I kind of like it but I hope it ages nicely. Rating (0-5) 3.5

Theodosius

In The Bottle Rich red musk with a hint of strawberry On Application I can definitely smell both musks which collide uncomfortably initially and then settle down to play nicer together. No fruit Dry Down It takes a wee while for the strawberry to emerge through the thick red musk, but when it does it turns the whole blend into a lovely, sweet musky and slightly powdery scent. My male skin turns "girly" scents into smokey, sexy scents. I love it. Rating (0-5) 4

In The Bottle Definitely a bit of lily of the valley and some resins On Application Awful rose Dry Down This goes funky rose/toilet spray after a while. Not a good mix for me. Rating (0-5) 0

In The Bottle Not much of anything. Slightly floral On Application Man. This is one of the most "perfumey" of BPALs I have tried. It's not screeching floral though. It is smooth and creamy and lovely Dry Down The vanilla note is gorgeous. It is not pervasive but it is just there mellowing everything out. Strangely this is like a floral Black Lace for me (and I love Black Lace) - subtly smokey and decadent. An instant bottle purchase for me. Rating (0-5) 5

In The Bottle Ylang ylang and woods On Application The iris quickly comes to the fore with it's vaguely violet-like scent Dry Down This definitely has a blue feel, or more like deep lavender. It is not exactly smooth but it is deep and complex. Morphs from creamy floral to woody to herbal and flits between these. Rating (0-5) 3

In The Bottle Sweet, creamy floral On Application Much greener on first application. Greenery with moonflower Dry Down Almost a fruity vibe to this. Has a definite tropical feel. I love moonflower but can't differentiate the other elements. Would be a great spring scent. Rating (0-5) 3.5

Crushed violets, red currant, patchouli root, and Spanish moss. In The Bottle Red Currant and patchouli when I was expecting violet On Application Strange. Thin oil and odd dustiness Dry Down I don't know what to say about this one other than it is a complete surprise. I stayed away from this one initially becasue I thought it would be VIOLET now I am definitely staying away from it because it is odd and funky Rating (0-5) 0

In The Bottle Definitely purple and creamy On Application Whoa! Plum with a floral undertone Dry Down Blends out to a great combination of all three elements. The plums are tart and juicy. The wildflowers are herby and very summery. The cream is thick and rich. The blend never turns sour although it has a couple of moments of almost doing that. I absolutely love this one. I really need to give Marchen more attention! Rating (0-5) 4.5

Kumari Kandam is quite icy for me

In The Bottle Incensey/patchouli On Application Dusty/dry/ Patchouli and copal. Love Dry Down This is so not what I was expecting from this blend. So dry and dusty it makes my nostrils shrivel up. I love it! Smells of an old wooden chest. No heliotrope. Rating (0-5) 4.5

In The Bottle Abolutely dragon's blood and musk. I might actually like this dragons blood blend On Application Straight, strong dragons blood Dry Down The musks very quickly assert themselves, thankfully, cutting through the dragons blood. And then the DB is back with a vengeance. The dry down is very nice though. Rating (0-5) 4

In The Bottle Definitely vetiver with a light floral overtone On Application Vetiver with a little musk and opoponax Dry Down This reminds me so much of Smokestack to start with - all bitter, smoky creosote - which I like. This softens as it dries down but effectively doesn't morph. I ike it but not enough for a bottle purchase, which is academic now anyway since it has been discontinued. Rating (0-5) 3

In The Bottle Hmmm...slightly fruity and slightly aquatic On Application Initially, kind of green but this changes almost immediately to salty aquatic and rum with almost a caramel undertone. Dry Down This is a really interesting morpher. The aquatic aspect is always there but the musky leather and patchouli emerge later but disappear on occasion to let the other elements through. Eventually I get the "tang' of gunpowder. I love it. Rating (0-5) 4.5