This will be my first review!!!
In an imp: I can definitely smell a sweetened (yet sour), subtle bit o' honey with milk and carnation hovering underneath both ever so slightly. It's a bittersweet first impression.
Wet on my skin: The bitterness of the milk and honey fades, and the carnation prominently moves into the foreground.
Dry: The carnation sticks around, and the rose comes out to play along with it. It has a powdery scent, but it's not as starch as baby powder. It lasts quite a while, too!
As a newbie to BPAL I appreciate the subtleness of this scent - much of the other imps I've purchased thus far have been a bit overwhelming. Alice is soft, light, and innocent. I particularly love that the floral notes have lingered longest on my skin. I definitely need to purchase a bottle!