izile

I know a lot of this has to do with skin chemistry but on a male friend of mine, both Coyote and Brown Jenkins smell like soft, warm, fur. On me, the Little Sparrow scent from the Marchen line is *very* soft, warm and furry (or downy, I suppose, depending).

I just resniffed White Moon after reading this thread. Yup! I get lilac now. *takes it OFF the swap pile* keeping that.

I Adore Lovers in a Ricefield Kitsune-Tsuki was one of my first loves I cannot get enough Prunella! Bensiable did something a little wonky on my skin and I smelled no plums or leather, though reading this makes me want to try it again. I, too, would love more plummy goodness!

I want to try Detox, now. I have Philosophy's 3-1 body wash in Margarita, and I love the smell, but it drives me mad that the scent washes down the drain, and I step out of the shower smelling like NOTHING!! It makes me so sad, and I always leave the shower wanting BPAL that smells like bright, alcoholic limes.

I loooove coconut, but I'm uber-picky about it. I want it to not be "fakey" like so many other companies' coconut scents are. OBATALA is my pure coconuts scent. The one that makes me feel like I just broke one open on a tropical beach and drank the milk and am chewing on the fresh meat. Elega is my second, as i do love a pina colada, even minus the pina part. It's sweeter, boozier, more drinky-drinky, but still lurvely. Black Pearl, I'm just trying again, but it comes out as having so many other notes in with it, where Obatala is just like "KING COCONUT" to me.

I've slowly (while trying to cover as much of the catalog as possible) been setting aside certain scents as "male." Normally, I give them to the guy who got me into BPAL in the first place by giving me all his imps. The ones he likes, he keeps, the rest I swap off. So far, these are the ones he's kept and I've approved are good on him. (Some I absolutely HATED until he tried them on) Anthony - Guy Baron Samedi - Guy Bensiabel - Guy Brown Jenkins - Guy Calico Jack - Guy Coyote - Guy Crowley - Guy Doc Constantine - Guy Dorian - Guy Grog - Guy Jolly Roger - Guy Libertine - Guy Lysander - Guy Oberon - Guy Nyarlanthotep - Guy Phoenix Steamworks - Guy Plunder - Guy Port Royal - Guy Saytr - Guy Snake Oil - Guy St. Germaine - Guy Tavern of Hell - Guy need to add, Velvet Dogs Playing Poker. I'd *LOVE* to smell that on a man.

Re: the environmental issue. I'm not knowledgable about this enough to know 100% for sure on this particular subject, but I know that in other cases, people often champion synthetics in the name of the environment, saying it's better than the natural because of mismanagement of the natural resource needed to produce the "natural product." However, they often overlook any environmental damage caused by the production of the synthetic substitute. I know this is the case with fabrics, where people will be against cotton, wools, silk, leathers, for various reasons; meanwhile acrylics, poly-fabrics and some other synthetics are developed from crude oil. Not only a non-renewable resource, but very environmentally unfriendly from the harvesting to the processing of the crude oil into these synthetics. Worst of all, these synthetic fabrics do not biodegrade and there are no recycling programs for them in the US. This is something that lots of people never consider or even hear about. Personally, I did a lot of personal research on that, and I avoid buying clothing items made with any petro-chemical synthetic fabrics, unless I find them in the thrift store. Last year, I almost managed to completely change my sweater selection over to Cashmere, Merino Wool, Silk and Cotton blends only. So, I know that's way OT here, but it's something I'd want to know about regarding certain synthetic alteratives. What are they made from? What is their chemical base? How do we get that chemical base?

Just wanted to add a note for the sensitive. When the anniversary scents first came out, I'd gotten a couple of imps of Candy Phoenix - worst most intense and immediate and PERSISTENT headache I've ever had to a scent. Scrubbing with soap wasn't enough, had to douse with vinegar and alcohol and scrub and then shower. WOW. And that wasn't a slather, just a light initial skin test.

I'm just mildly curious how others use their excel files. I download Hackess's brilliant piece of work as a base, then add a column on the far left where I can put "X" for keeping an imp "5ml" (obvious) "'--'" for had but swapped off, and "y" for giving to males. And recently just added "MNS" for those sniffed at Meet and Sniffs. Then I go back through with color coding. I see a lot of people mention color coding, but curious to know how they color code. Ones I've tried that I SERIOUSLY never want to smell again, highlighted in red. 5mls are dark blue-green, loved imps are neon green, and then everything in between loved and hated is somewhere on the color spectrum between red and green, with yellow being "meh" or "undecided" anybody else?

I have nothing *against* synthetic ingredients on a moral or ethical basis, but I have to admit, I do like the fact BPAL uses no synthetics and it's one reason they're the only perfume I've ever bought. Before I discovered BPAL I was allergic to basically all perfume I'd ever been exposed to. Even if a perfume (like Philosophy's lines) didn't make me sneeze, I tended to break out in a rash. Then again, I'm also one of those freaky individuals that has really bad reactions to synthetics that were specifically invented because a lot of people have bad reactions to the natural version. (I'm allergic to synthetic penicillin, but not real penicillin; I can eat all natural ice creams like Breyers, but if I get one of the kinds with the huge paragraph list of ingredients, I'm going to be in the bathroom *all night* in pain; I have a better chance of coping with rare chicken or pork than a properly prepared frozen dinner.) So, whatever Beth does, I appreciate it! Because otherwise, I would still be living in a perfume-devoid world!

It showed up the day after I posted this (ha!) of course, now I have new issues to figure out how to address, like part of my order was wrong. but that's for another thread.

Has there been any more news since the last update regarding express postage upgrades for those who purchased prior to Dec 13th? I'm getting a little antsy, as the shipment is being delivered to Mississippi, and I *really* need it to show up BEFORE my plane takes me back to New York after the holidays are over. I can cope with it not making Christmas, but showing up *after* I've shipped back out would be a giant pain in the ass. *frets*

Am I the only one who doesn't know how to say this one? Bensiable It's the end bit that gets me, I don't want to say a man's name that ends in "bell" So, is it Ben-syble? as in the old Hebrew thing of "Ben" meaning "son" and the witch being named "Syble"? or Ben-see-able? or Ben-see-ah-bull?

Speaking of bat's day. I cannot find a review of Chiroptera *anywhere* I've got an imp of it coming, and would like to know what to expect. I keep trying to use bpal's forum search, but it gives me bubpkis. anybody?

This is just the topic I needed! So, knowing that I'm a rabid BPAL-er now, my boss's boyfriend brought me a smelly dilemma today. He brought in his old roller ball of Nag Champa that he used to get from some place that apparently stopped making it (it was just a random indian shop here in the city). He's tried ordering from other places and it's not the same. He brought me his recent order of Nag Champa from a place off the internet (having already been around the city and not found the same scent) and the difference was HUGE. Thing is, his old Nag Champa smelled a bit like Snake Oil to me. It was resinous, woody but very warm with a kind of buttery vanilla tone to it. But, not being able to bring his precious few remaining drops back to my lab, er, I mean apartment, it's hard to compare what's under my nose now to what was under my nose several hours ago. Just got a sniffie of Cottonmouth in today as well, and again, it smells *similar* I guess I'm just hoping the ow wise gurus of the forum will know more than me and be able to make recommendations and suggestions.

How about the winter LE "Rose Red" compared to the new Marchen "The Rose" both their descriptions sound like they should smell mainly the same. is it too soon for anyone to know the answer to this one?

*curious* does anyone know if there's Cinnamon oil in Snake Oil? I think it was Hellfire that I had, and it BURNED. I mean, heat, inflamation, redness at the site. It wasn't even me (I knew better) the guy who gave it to me warned me not to apply it to the skin, because he'd had that reaction, and then I told the girl I gave it to the same thing, and she didn't listen and almost immediately went running to the bathroom screaming "ow ow hot hot hot!" I know straight cinnamon oil can do that, not just as an allergy, but just because it's that way (it's the burny/tingly/plumpy oil in a lot of lip plumpers) -Izile

Allgeries are the main reason I've stayed away from perfume my whole life. BPAL had been amazingly non-sneezey for me. . . until. I got an imp of Midnight in, I liked the smell, tested it on my skin, and all night, headache, runny nose, sneezing, watery itchy eyes. DEFINITELY allergic. It's the only one I've had that reaction to, and there's so many notes in it, it makes me wonder which one is the most likely culprit.