O is definitely my favorite of all the BPAL scents I've tried. It ages beautifully.
In the bottle: I can definitely smell the honey and the amber.
Wet- Still smells like honey and amber but I'm definitely getting a little more vanilla.
Dry- The amber becomes a lot more prevalent on me, but the honey and vanilla are still there.
Notes: On my skin this scent has a lot of throw and it really sticks to stuff. My coats and scarves really smell like it, and it lasts for a long time on my skin.