As a book lover I can't help but try as many of the bookish BPAL scents I can get my hands on...
Imp: Spicy and full of incense-y deliciousness; I think I can smell the musk as well. Sniffing from the wand, there's something sharpish and acerbic that smells really familiar, though I can't place it.
Wet: Sweetish incense and, oh dear...
Drying/Dry: Powder, powder, powder. Further from my wrist I get a touch of musky sweetness but it's quite overpowered. I can smell the sharpness I smelled in the imp on my skin as well - it's not straight up baby powder, but sweet floral powder. Other reviewers mentioned florals - I wonder if there's carnation, my arch-nemesis, in this.
Sadly, I don't get any incense or bookish smells at all; back to the imp box it goes.