Thank you for the suggestions, sharkdiver! The Gas Lamps Flare caught my eye when I saw it on the NYCC list, but Poisoned Apple sounds nice as well and is much more easily available.
I've notice that some people's skin just doesn't seem to like certain notes, so I'm still concerned about whether my skin is going to make all apple notes smell like candles. I will just have to try a few more and see.