Jump to content
Post-Update: Forum Issues Read more... ×
BPAL Madness!

RoseThornAndOak

Members
  • Content Count

    631
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by RoseThornAndOak

  1. RoseThornAndOak

    Archangel Winter

    This is for the 2007 version. I really should wear this more because it's a very nice ozoney aquatic that never goes screechy, just soft, clean, and wearable. It doesn't read floral to me, much more aquatic ozone, but perhaps the florals are what soften it. I can see this being very unisex and smell amazing on a man (not that florals can't be refined on a man, naturalich). Damn this is really good, fresh, and clean, it's good for all year round, imo. I think if you enjoy Lightning but want something less... jolting 🌩️ ... you may enjoy Archangel Winter.
  2. RoseThornAndOak

    Lucy’s Room Home & Linen Spray

    Happy Wolf Moon, everyone! I am happy to announce this is a very nice sweet girlfriend to Lycan Lace, without the tobacco and earth notes. It for sure is reminiscent of a lace blend. It is sweet, light, fresh, floral, powdery, and feminine in a vintage sort of way, but this never ever smells like an old cologne, just charming and pretty. I could see Lucy's room smelling like this (minus the garlic strands, of course). The honey note is either nonexistent or very well blended, which is a good thing for me, so I will be lurking the Trading Post to see if this becomes a perfume oil. Overall very happy with this and thank you to the above reviewers. I get the lavender in the bottle thing too, but not once it is sprayed. I highly recommend this for fans of ...maybe Tattered Lace and Antique Lace, but it is still very different from them, lighter and more powdery floral. Maybe Lullaby fans. -sniffs- yes, closer to Lullaby with less lavender, maybe a dried rosey cousin, or a sister to Veil, but this really is its own scent.
  3. RoseThornAndOak

    Zorya Polunochnaya

    This one is very soft, pretty, and light. It starts out with the light AL type of vanilla and a slight metallic note, then dries down to a slightly more floral cross between AL and Mouses Long and Sad Tale. It wears close to the skin. Very lovely. I have a dupe of Vanilla Lace that works even better but this will get lots and lots of wear. For fans of Antique Lace, Mouses Long and Sad Tale, Lullaby, and Moonshine and Mist.
  4. RoseThornAndOak

    Come, Sister

    Come Sister started out a very lovely white floral with nuances of a finishing powder. After 15 minutes it quickly did the same thing the iris in Lucy Westenra from OOTD1 did and went straight to a powdery floral Play-Doh. The individual notes are very different in each blend so I find it odd that Come Sister smells like it. I will see how it ages and try it as a locket scent because I really enjoy the florals in the opening. Edit: The drydown is much better now. The play-doh phase was much shorter lived and I really like this! It's a nice, unassuming, not going to punch you in the face white floral. Not my personal favorite, but I will still reach for this. 😃
  5. RoseThornAndOak

    Whirling Wind Moon

    Given the floral notes I would've thought this would work but it is more of an evergreen/ozoney type scent. It kind of does what goes wrong on me in Kumaru Kandam. There are wintery blends I love more, but it will work well for an atmos spray for sure.
  6. RoseThornAndOak

    Fairy Wine

    Oh man, I wish I was getting what many of you are! The wine note goes sour on my skin and doesn't blend well at all! There is a moment during drydown where it does this peaceful fairy wine, meadowy pleasant florally thing, then turns total crackhouse, musty, and bitter. Ah well. It's also more red wine than effervescent. I'll stick with Bon Vivant.
  7. RoseThornAndOak

    German Expressionist Horror

    Dude I'm just gonna say it. This smells like a musty old pine box and reminds me of my grandpa's trailer in the woods in a not a good way. It just kinda stays that way, too.
  8. RoseThornAndOak

    Night Thoughts

    '08. Mighty fine lovely floral keeper with a reasonable bit of ozone, bordering on aquatic. A bit like Grief or Ode on Melancholy. No cedary pencil shavings, praise Whatever. Why did this just kinda sit in a box for 11 years? It doesn't beat the bombastic Thalassa aquatic floral but it's pretty dang pretty.
  9. RoseThornAndOak

    Frostbitten Snake Oil

    Not too shabs. The original Snake Oil goes a bit waxy on me and not in a good way, just a "meh, it's okay" way. I was hoping this would work a bit better. It definitely has the Snow White/Snow-Flakes note, but dries down more Snake Oil. So if you love the original SO and/or SW or SF definitely try it. I prefer, SF, Pink Snowballs, and Mega-sized Chocolate Bar SO but very happy to have tried this. 😃
  10. RoseThornAndOak

    Frostbitten Bliss

    It's pretty darn nice. Snow-Flakes/Snow White plus a decent chocolate note. If I didn't already have Snow-Flakes and Pink Snowballs I would consider hunting this down, but the decant will certainly do. For fans of Mega-sized Chocolate Snake Oil also.
  11. RoseThornAndOak

    Lust

    This one's...interesting. I get a smutty red musk darkened by patchouli but it never really smells like patchouli, it just smells...smuttied I guess? Madame Moriarty works better imo, however I like it and will keep the imp around. Gender neutral.
  12. RoseThornAndOak

    Liz

    Liz is beautiful and very nostalgic for me. The bottle has aged very well over the past decade and seems to have remained very much what I remember: a very lovely soft floral leather blend. There is something cold and metallic about it, like steel or copper in a way, sort of like Copper or Silver Phoenix, but the florals soften it up and make it wearable. Usually leather is a bit iffy, but this never goes in that new car smell territory, thank goodness. It's more moto jacket, I guess. This is very fitting of Liz, and also reminds me of a character in The Good Neighbors, part fae, part rock n' roll. Actually yeah, this is a very elf-punk appropriate blend and I really should be getting more use out of it.
  13. RoseThornAndOak

    Dancing Among the Tombs

    Oo this is lovely. Sometimes a scent will kinda match a certain mood, in a specific place, with music and everything. Dancing Among The Tombs to me is sitting in a graveyard during a stormy summer evening in the South, your ripped up jeans getting muddied and grassy, hanging out with your friends, rocking out to Gish, Dirt, and Vulgar Display of Power. You're having a good time, you're buoyant and lighthearted, there's dandelions and other dewy wildflowers about, dirt, gravestones, you're taking silly photos of yourselves with "orbs" flying about and pigeons that scare the bejesus out of you, you may or may not have sprayed on some Gap Grass earlier. Your crush is a bit more dark and moody, brooding by himself, wearing Dorian over there and you're trying very, very hard to not act like a total asshat around him and probably failing miserably. Ultimately its a... lighthearted graveyard scent. Its Dancing Amongst The Tombs. I freakin love this and glad I snagged a full bottle!
  14. RoseThornAndOak

    Lycan Lace

    VetchVesper's review on Lycan Lace pretty much sold me on this blend and I was lucky enough to snag a bottle of this on Ebay. I'm kind of shocked there were no other bidders, because holy smokes is this lovely. It starts off dusty rose and creamy vanilla paired with tobacco, very haunted and antique, but not overtly cologne or perfume-like. The drydown is dessicated and powdery rose with a soft tobacco/incense supporting it. I would not say it is a head shop incense in the slightest, much more like Eve or The Antikythera Mechanism in its ancientness, not resinous really, but just a nice powdery dry incense. Actually I highly recommend this if you are a fan of either of those two, or if you have tried Black Baccara Perfumes 1983 or Benefit Cosmetics Dr. Feelgood Mattifying Balm, they have a very similar scent profile. The dirt note grounds and darkens this without turning it too sharp. I thankfully don't really get the pine note. Overall this is a huge win and the way the powdery rose warms up on the skin with the incense, tobacco, and feral musk makes for a romantic and strangely comforting and snuggly skin scent, or if you are a sexy vampire flying down the freeway betching about Louis ("FOR CENTURIES!!") that is completely befitting, too.
  15. RoseThornAndOak

    Dark Lace

    Oh wow this is lovely. The vegetal and incense notes blended with the cleaner lace, and creamy cognac/vanilla/tobacco notes give it a haunted house vibe while still being perfectly wearable as a perfume/cologne. While the 2 original Black Laces went a bit dryer sheet on drydown, I found Dark Lace to be more reminiscent of Lycan Lace: dark, vampiric, and sexy, what you would wear to a King Diamond show, then snuggle up and watch Christopher Lee and Vincent Price flicks after. I would say Lycan Lace is a bit more powdery, desiccated rose lace with dirt notes (totally Lestat fixing his lacy cuffs as another review mentioned), Dark Lace is for sure well, darker, yet clean. God damn this is sexy. I love how unabashedly romantic Lycan Lace warms up on the skin, and how sophisticated and nostalgic Dark Lace is. Fans of Black Lace, Lycan Lace, Gothic Horror, Eve, Wulric The Wolfman, Midnight on The Midway, and/or The Antikythera Mechanism might enjoy this.
  16. RoseThornAndOak

    A Lady Tall and White

    This is piney. A soft, delicate pine. It conjures images of soft, white snow and fabric, but it mostly smells like the pine needles with soap. Its delicate. Pine doesn't play nice on my skin, but I'll let it age and see. Snow Flakes works better for me. However, if you were a fan of Cloister Graveyard in The Snow or missed it, this one is similar from what I can remember, although I would have to try them on side by side to give you a full comparison.
  17. RoseThornAndOak

    Haunted

    Well it hasn't gone sour with my skin chemistry yet, so that's good. It did go sharp soap on, with something extra. Its actually kinda creeping me out, almost like attracting ghosts or something. Kinda powdery. I'll let it age and see what happens.
  18. RoseThornAndOak

    The Black Rider

    Yay for frimps! Especially ones you were already curious about. In fresh-from-the-lab (+ a few days) imp: Interesting. Masculine. Well blended. Wet on skin: Almost emotional, visual reaction. Its hard to say whether it smells like black leather, or just gives the impression of it like the spirit of it rather than the actual physical leather. The tobacco is clinging to the fabric. ...this has a creepy feel, like Ichabod better watch out before Mr. Darkness rides out of the woods with his cape flying in the moonlight, tattering up tobacco fields. Holy shit. Makes me think of black metal, too. Satyricon sort of stuff. Drydown: Well that was fun while it lasted. There's a sharp soap smell coming off it now. Maybe the amber? Its like if Ichabod defended himself with the shaving water basin, that's it. That's on top of the woody...I wanna say piney note but its not its...hard to describe. Just woody. Might let this baby age. There was a glimmer of Antikythera's yumminess for a bit there, before the soapiness hit, so it may work out eventually. Very little sourness, so that's good! Yeah just kinda sharp soapy now, but this would work wonders on the right skin. I'd love to smell this on a man. If tobacco, amber, and leather work well on you, give it a go! I just have strange chemistry.
  19. RoseThornAndOak

    Autumn Lace

    In bottle: Rich and sweet with an old world feel and an afterglow of sharp soap. Wet on skin: the same, with more richness coming forth. Drydown: This has a sharp powder note coming through. Nothing like the yum of Antique Lace or Tattered Lace on me. Actually Snow Flakes smells closer to Tattered Lace than this does to my nose. Its powder with a touch of boozy depth. Achoo! Sneeze not good! Later: Autumn Lace has more similarity to Gothic Horror on me than Tattered Lace or Antique Lace. It has a dark, perfumey quality. Sadly the powder note is amping the most. It just doesn't have the sweetness I was hoping and aging it didn't help my case. This little girl needs a new bud.
  20. RoseThornAndOak

    Pumpkin IV (2008)

    '08 version: The sweet pumpkin part is nice, but the sharp note is ruining it for my chemistry. =( I has a sad! Nice and rich in the bottle, might make a good room scent or rock on the right person!
  21. RoseThornAndOak

    Fae

    In the imp (aged): Kinda smells like a vintage perfume bottle that has dried up over the years, but sweetier and fruitier. Wet on skin: Fruit with powder, but there IS a gossamer sort of quality to it. Drydown: Oh darn my chemistry, its going to straight powder-wait. There's something playful and fun behind it if I smell closely. Its kinda like a blanket of cleanliness and soap with a cute little fruit-smelling creature beneath it. Maybe the peach? Hmm. I wanted to like this one as I love peaches and all things faerie, but alas its mostly soapy heliotrope for me. I'm still looking for the perfect fae-like/huldrfolk scent. Glittering Apple of The Stars gives more of an otherworldly quality and works much better on my skin than Fae. Its kinda morphing into something vaguely nice, but this would be much better for someone who is looking for a clean/powder scent with a hint of fruit. =)
  22. RoseThornAndOak

    Muse of the Night

    I wanted to like this blend so much! The imagery reminded me of The Smashing Pumpkins' Mellon Collie and The Infinite Sadness, a favorite album, so I was delighted to see the last person to post a review's SN is Porcelina! This blend smells fruity and whispy in the bottle and wet on skin. It soon turns soapy/powdery in the drydown, with the fruit coming through intermittently. Even now that it is aged it still smells of powder on me, unfortunately. Hopefully the two bottles I bought will go to a good home.
×