Been dancing the BPAL dance for 4-ish years, but this is my first post! Hurrah!
My top 5:
1. Jazz Funeral
2. Brown Jenkin
3. Sea of Glass
4. The Great Sword of War
5. Samhain
Runner-ups: Harlot (loved as much as the top 5, but lasted about 1 hr on me), Anathema, Blood Kiss, Dorian
I'm putting together a new order right now, leaning towards both dark, earthy scents and aquatics. I'm very new to aquatics, but I've loved all I've tried!