This was one of the first BPAL apple notes I've tried and I've gotta say, they do apple really well!
Apple I is a creamy, slightly nutty apple and milk scent. It's warm and comforting but not cloying at all. I love that the honey isn't overpowering because it does tend to make scents heavy. When dry, it smells of creamy goat milk and vanilla with oats. It is SO lovely.