Koumori Report post Posted January 25, 2017 Ding Dong Ditch! Black Phoenix Alchemy Lab's Samhain scent with cinnamon sugar and candy dust! I picked this one up off Etsy. This will teach me to read the reviews before I do this, as I can see this atmo is very divisive and unfortunately I come down on the "no!" side. I love Samhain, but this isn't that. I love cinnamon and sugar, but this isn't that either. There's a sour component in here that I find very unpleasant- maybe even something like the pickles others have described. The vinegar/sour/decayed off note that I get unfortunately doesn't fade away, and I imagine I will put this up for swap or sale. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
doomsday_disco Report post Posted January 28, 2020 I was gifted a decant of this one and had the same experience as the above reviewer. I once had Samhain Atmo, which I ended up destashing because the scent was so strong that it was overwhelming to me. This doesn't smell like Samhain to me at all, although it is also overwhelming. It's very sour, and there's also a leaf-y scent beneath the sourness. I get no Samhain, cinnamon sugar, or candy from this whatsoever, sadly. I sprayed this on a paper towel to test this and ended up having to throw the paper towel away because the scent was so bothersome. It seems like there may be a batch variation with this one according to the reviews? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
fairybites Report post Posted February 23, 2021 This is amazing, one of the best atmospheric sprays I've tried! I only get the cinnamon and sugar when I first spray it really, it dries to be mostly Samhain with extra sweetness. The dominant notes from Samhain I get in this are the apple and pumpkin. If I didn't know Samhain was in this, I would think it smelled like fried apples and sugar. Definitely try picking this up if you adore Samhain! I haven't tried the regular Samhain atmo, but I think these might be pretty comparable. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
LilyWhorror Report post Posted May 22, 2021 This smells exactly like fresh cut grass to me. How is that possible?? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
broccoliwitch Report post Posted September 13, 2022 I grabbed this from a lot of atmos on ebay and I feel so lucky that i'm getting both Samhain (leaves, spices, pumpkin) and the cinnamon sugar/candy dust! This is perfect for this time of year and is putting me in a wonderful fall mood. It also lasts all day (and night) so I really only need a couple sprays in 1 room every fews days and it scents the whole top floor of my place. I would love to be able to get more of this! Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
