Ashmedai Report post Posted August 19, 2012 Yes I want to smell like a vegetable garden. From last year's Halloween and Yule updates, I ordered Garden of Death, Mandrake Charm, Breathless Horror and Solitary and Abhorred. All of these have vegetable notes, and I've gone absolutely bonkers over them. From the GC I've also found Mandrake, Beer From the Marshwoman's Brewery and Garden Path With Chickens, which I love just as much. I'm curious if there are any other vegetable garden scents that have gone under my radar, ones that can (but don't have to) contain herbs as well, preferably ones where the soil note isn't all that prominent, there are no fruit notes and where any florals are muted or not present. Eh - that may sound a little nitpicky and too specific, but I'm open to any suggestions. Thanks! Share this post Link to post
lanas Report post Posted August 19, 2012 I think Planting Moon just may be perfect for you. The notes are -Budding summer squashes and pole beans, tomato leaves, upturned earth, May's wildflowers, and sun-warmed herbs. I don't get much soil or floral from it, mostly warm green herbs. Share this post Link to post
joyfulgirl Report post Posted August 19, 2012 DEFINITELY check out the witch's garden...i know it lists morning glory vines, but i got literally NO floral at all from this...it was all green and herbal. "Morning glory vines twisting around a patch of rampion, carrot, and parsley, with monkshood, hemlock, elfwort, sage, wormwood, and mandrake." http://www.bpal.org/topic/50716-the-witchs-garden/ also maybe karme, if you can hunt down an imp..."Sun-warmed squashes, peppers, salad greens, snap peas, radishes, green onions, and silphium." http://www.bpal.org/topic/75407-karme/ good luck! Share this post Link to post
Ashmedai Report post Posted August 19, 2012 Oh wow - that sounds right up my alley. I haven't seen much of that around in swaps or sales, but one can always hope. Thanks! I think Planting Moon just may be perfect for you. The notes are -Budding summer squashes and pole beans, tomato leaves, upturned earth, May's wildflowers, and sun-warmed herbs. I don't get much soil or floral from it, mostly warm green herbs. Share this post Link to post
Ashmedai Report post Posted August 19, 2012 That sounds fantasic, and it's going right on my ISO list. I've been dying to try Karme, and was lucky to swap for a decant with a great forumite just last week. Can't wait to try it, but I already have a feeling I'll be looking for more. Thanks for the recs and for good luck wishes! DEFINITELY check out the witch's garden...i know it lists morning glory vines, but i got literally NO floral at all from this...it was all green and herbal. "Morning glory vines twisting around a patch of rampion, carrot, and parsley, with monkshood, hemlock, elfwort, sage, wormwood, and mandrake." http://www.bpal.org/topic/50716-the-witchs-garden/ also maybe karme, if you can hunt down an imp..."Sun-warmed squashes, peppers, salad greens, snap peas, radishes, green onions, and silphium." http://www.bpal.org/topic/75407-karme/ good luck! Share this post Link to post
Little Bird Report post Posted August 19, 2012 Hagsgate is one of my favorites for a veggie scent (from The Last Unicorn series): "An accursed bounty: rich black soil and hay, cucumber, tomato, red lettuce, summer squash, black eggplant, arugula, grape vine, artichoke, and a tangle of herbs marred by an undercurrent of vetiver, patchouli, and black moss." Share this post Link to post
dIMPles Report post Posted August 19, 2012 I was going to mention Karme as well! I have not tried these others, but thought I would mention them. Of course if you don't like chocolate, they likely won't be much help . Dark Chocolate with Sun-Dried Tomato, Pink Peppercorn, Thyme and Comfrey and to a lesser degree Dark Chocolate with Tulsi, Tumeric and White Ginger Hope you find lots of wonderful smellies! Share this post Link to post
Ashmedai Report post Posted August 19, 2012 Oh yeah, that's on my ISO list already and a definite planned purchase if I don't find it in a swap. I had a tester recently gifted to me and loved it immediately. Hagsgate is one of my favorites for a veggie scent (from The Last Unicorn series): "An accursed bounty: rich black soil and hay, cucumber, tomato, red lettuce, summer squash, black eggplant, arugula, grape vine, artichoke, and a tangle of herbs marred by an undercurrent of vetiver, patchouli, and black moss." Share this post Link to post
Ashmedai Report post Posted August 19, 2012 I can't wait to try Karme. Fortunately I've seen this or that decant up for swap or sale if I love it as much as I think I will. Hmm, chocolate can go either way with me, but I give every BPAL a chance and I have to say these do sound very intriguing. Thanks! I was going to mention Karme as well! I have not tried these others, but thought I would mention them. Of course if you don't like chocolate, they likely won't be much help . Dark Chocolate with Sun-Dried Tomato, Pink Peppercorn, Thyme and Comfrey and to a lesser degree Dark Chocolate with Tulsi, Tumeric and White Ginger Hope you find lots of wonderful smellies! Share this post Link to post
StinkyPinky Report post Posted August 19, 2012 Has anyone mentioned Gorg's Garden? I don't know how that would be in terms of soil prominence/dominance, but it sounds like it might be your kind of thing. Share this post Link to post
Ashmedai Report post Posted August 19, 2012 It does sound like it - definitely putting out a wish for a decant or tester. How did I miss this one? *scratches ear in befuddlement* Thanks! Has anyone mentioned Gorg's Garden? I don't know how that would be in terms of soil prominence/dominance, but it sounds like it might be your kind of thing. Share this post Link to post
Ashmedai Report post Posted August 20, 2012 I tried that one, it was too aquatic for me and missed that deep, rooty soil/growing things I love. I may have to re-test it though, since my scent preferences have expanded the more BPAL I tested, and I tested this one years back. Thanks! Squirting Cucumber! Share this post Link to post
FragranceLush Report post Posted August 20, 2012 I just tested an imp of Jerusalem Cherry Infused Honey and find it to have a strong vegetal note. In fact, the honey pretty much disappeared on me after the first 15 min, something the lab's honey notes have never done before. jerusalem cherry is a plant related to evening nightshade and tomatoes I think - the green note is more like tomato leaf than anything else I can think of. Not at all herbal to my nose. It was a 2010 LD but I think I have seen it out there from time to time. Share this post Link to post
Gwydion Report post Posted August 21, 2012 (edited) I think Planting Moon just may be perfect for you. The notes are -Budding summer squashes and pole beans, tomato leaves, upturned earth, May's wildflowers, and sun-warmed herbs. I don't get much soil or floral from it, mostly warm green herbs. That is my favorite garden scent. Mmmmm... tomato leaf The original worm moon was very fresh planting. Edited August 21, 2012 by Gwydion Share this post Link to post
Ashmedai Report post Posted August 21, 2012 I really have to try that. I skipped right over it since I concluded "cherry" and "honey" (both not good on me), I never would have guessed tomatoes - lol. I just tested an imp of Jerusalem Cherry Infused Honey and find it to have a strong vegetal note. In fact, the honey pretty much disappeared on me after the first 15 min, something the lab's honey notes have never done before. jerusalem cherry is a plant related to evening nightshade and tomatoes I think - the green note is more like tomato leaf than anything else I can think of. Not at all herbal to my nose. It was a 2010 LD but I think I have seen it out there from time to time. Share this post Link to post
Ashmedai Report post Posted August 21, 2012 Is that Worm Moon 2008? Sounds intriguing - thanks! I think Planting Moon just may be perfect for you. The notes are -Budding summer squashes and pole beans, tomato leaves, upturned earth, May's wildflowers, and sun-warmed herbs. I don't get much soil or floral from it, mostly warm green herbs. That is my favorite garden scent. Mmmmm... tomato leaf The original worm moon was very fresh planting. Share this post Link to post
Gwydion Report post Posted August 22, 2012 <br />Is that Worm Moon 2008? Sounds intriguing - thanks! <img src='http://www.bpal.org/public/style_emoticons/default/icon_smile.gif' class='bbc_emoticon' alt='' /><br /><br /><br /><br /><br />I think Planting Moon just may be perfect for you. The notes are -Budding summer squashes and pole beans, tomato leaves, upturned earth, May's wildflowers, and sun-warmed herbs. I don't get much soil or floral from it, mostly warm green herbs.<br /><br /><br />That is my favorite garden scent. Mmmmm... tomato leaf<br /><br />The original worm moon was very fresh planting.<br /><br /><br /><br /><br /> Yes. Share this post Link to post
stellamaris Report post Posted August 22, 2012 What about AE Albopictus? Tomato leaf, very good... Share this post Link to post
aisling Report post Posted August 22, 2012 Virgo 2007 smells like a vegetable patch on me. Virgo 2007 Mutable earth: the essence of analysis. Fennel, valerian, maidenhair fern, carrot seed, honeysuckle, and myrtle. Share this post Link to post
Ashmedai Report post Posted August 22, 2012 That really does sound great - and fortunately still available. Thanks! What about AE Albopictus? Tomato leaf, very good... Share this post Link to post
Ashmedai Report post Posted August 22, 2012 Just read some reviews, and this sounds incredibly awesome. Thanks for the rec! Virgo 2007 smells like a vegetable patch on me. Virgo 2007 Mutable earth: the essence of analysis. Fennel, valerian, maidenhair fern, carrot seed, honeysuckle, and myrtle. Share this post Link to post
portalkat Report post Posted August 22, 2012 Another LE, but Pumpkin Patch III from 2009 had tomato leaf. The description is: Pumpkin, fir needle, pitch, rosemary, and tomato. I love it. It's one of my favorite pumpkins because of the tomato leaf. Share this post Link to post
Gwydion Report post Posted August 24, 2012 What about AE Albopictus? Tomato leaf, very good... Ooo! I love that one. Share this post Link to post
Ashmedai Report post Posted August 24, 2012 That really does sound intriguing - I need to find that. Thanks! Another LE, but Pumpkin Patch III from 2009 had tomato leaf. The description is: Pumpkin, fir needle, pitch, rosemary, and tomato. I love it. It's one of my favorite pumpkins because of the tomato leaf. Share this post Link to post