That same butter/sweet cream note as Bread & Butterfly

[andabri]

I'm looking for a scent that has that same butter/sweet cream note as Bread & Butterfly. Or a similar creamy feel. I love it. LOVE LOVE LOVE.

 

I thought maybe Boo would, but it doesn't on me. Also thought Detestable Putrescence doesn't either.

 

The closest I've found is the creaminess of Miskatonic University (which I love also).

 

I do have a decant of Ivory Vulva coming... but I am very weary of coconut. Though I couldn't pass it up because of the cream accord listed.

 

Also just sweet milky, or sweet cakey recs.

 

I tried out Eat Me, which I don't get any cake from. Strangely enough I get cake from Mermaid, a lot more than in Eat Me.

[Balame]

It's been a long time since I smelled B&B, but from what I remember Dana O'Shee has a similar sweet, milky, foody feel (Offerings of milk, honey and sweet grains were made to placate these creatures, and it is that the basis of the scent created in their name). Too sweet for me but you may like it.

 

The best sweet cake/bread I've smelled is Delight and Consternation (Bourbon vanilla, custard accord, white rose, cocoa absolute, oudh, lemon blossom, and skin musk) which is like the most delicious lemon tart ever. And for a more incense-y cake All Souls is amazing. Definitely has a buttery, lip-licking vibe to it.

 

Sprinkle Cake and Very Pink Surprise Cake are the others I can think of. Surprise Cake was a truer cake to me while Sprinkle was a little too candy sweet, though of course your experience might be different.

[andabri]

It's been a long time since I smelled B&B, but from what I remember Dana O'Shee has a similar sweet, milky, foody feel (Offerings of milk, honey and sweet grains were made to placate these creatures, and it is that the basis of the scent created in their name). Too sweet for me but you may like it.

 

The best sweet cake/bread I've smelled is Delight and Consternation (Bourbon vanilla, custard accord, white rose, cocoa absolute, oudh, lemon blossom, and skin musk) which is like the most delicious lemon tart ever. And for a more incense-y cake All Souls is amazing. Definitely has a buttery, lip-licking vibe to it.

 

Sprinkle Cake and Very Pink Surprise Cake are the others I can think of. Surprise Cake was a truer cake to me while Sprinkle was a little too candy sweet, though of course your experience might be different.

 

Thank you so much! It was hard to for me to "properly" search, I think, because there are so many LE scents! This gives me a great list to research.

[Lady_Fire]

I think you may also like Alice from the Mad Tea Party collection. The notes are milk and honey with rose, carnation and bergamot. All Souls is a beautiful cakey incense scent, though I find it wears close to the skin. Should you ever have the chance, I think you'd LOVE Reflected Vulva from last years shungas. It's very rare and coveted though. I also think Dana O'Shee would be a good one for you to try. It's a very comforting scent.

[sprout]

Cockaigne from the general catalog is very much buttery cakes for me. For creamy I suggest Dragons Milk. I have not tried layering them but I bet that would be heavenly. Dragons milk isn't heavy with dbr if that gives you pause.

[stellamaris]

Knave of Hearts has a very strong buttery note for me.

[sprout]

Forgot to mention Hellcat. Yummy butterscotch but dries down to buttery vanilla.

[andabri]

Yay, thanks everyone I put all these down on my list. I'm waiting for Bread and Butterfly to come back in stock (it's been OOS for a long time, is it one of those scents that is rarely in stock?) and I'll get all the ones I'm able to when I order that.

[Laura Lee Smith]

I prefer Drink me to Eat me for creaminess. Drink me smells like butter and cherry on me, then dries down to a warm sweet scent but that butter note is delicious.

[BetteNoire]

My Baby and a Baby Goat is creamy and buttery. It's currently available, and very pretty.

[LizziesLuck]

Yay, thanks everyone I put all these down on my list. I'm waiting for Bread and Butterfly to come back in stock (it's been OOS for a long time, is it one of those scents that is rarely in stock?) and I'll get all the ones I'm able to when I order that.

Maybe you've already realized this but it was discontinued.

[sprout]

Movie Night, one of the current Lilith scents, is mostly butter on me. I get strawberry licorice candy at first, but then it is all buttered popcorn, emphasis on butter. The corn part isn't really there on my skin. Or, if you can track down Shill, it is all buttery popcorn but it is hard to find. HTH